A $75,000 settlement could not turn into a $300,000 judgment
Vitatech Internat., Inc. v. Sporn (2017) 16 Cal.App.5th 796 · California Court of Appeal
What happened
A manufacturer sued a customer and its guarantor for about $166,000 in unpaid invoices. The defendants denied liability. On the eve of trial the parties settled for a single payment of $75,000. The defendants also signed a stipulation for entry of judgment “in the full prayer of the Complaint,” which the manufacturer agreed to hold unless they missed the payment date. They missed it. The manufacturer filed the stipulation and the court entered judgment for more than $300,000, including interest, attorney fees, and costs.
What the court decided
The Court of Appeal ordered the judgment vacated and replaced with a judgment for $75,000 plus trial court costs. A judgment for more than four times the settlement amount bore no reasonable relationship to the harm a late payment could cause. That made it an unenforceable penalty, and a judgment built on a penalty is void and can be set aside. Calling the $75,000 a “discount” did not help, because the defendants had never admitted they owed the larger sum.