BENJY LAW CORPORATION

Judgment Creditor Resources · Part VI of VI

Keeping the judgment alive and getting paid

A California money judgment lasts ten years unless you renew it, and the lien needs its own renewal step. This part covers renewal, appeals, bankruptcy, partial payments, satisfaction, and judgments from other states and countries.

4 war storiesCalifornia lawFrom War Stories from the Judgment Docket

Talk to a lawyer: (310) 203-2650

General information about California law, not legal advice. Reading this does not create an attorney-client relationship.

In this part · 4 war stories
  1. 26He paid the damages and froze the fee award
  2. 27The check marked “full and complete satisfaction”
  3. 28The landlords who would not cash the checks
  4. 29Seventeen months was too long to wait
Judgment Creditor FAQ →

Many judgments are collected years after they are entered. Debtors sell a house, inherit, or start earning again. A creditor who kept the judgment and its liens alive is first in line. A creditor who let the ten years run has nothing.

This part is about the long game: renewing on time, what an appeal or a bankruptcy does to collection, how payments are credited, what you owe the debtor once you are paid, and how to bring a judgment from another state or country into California.

The ten-year clock

Appeals and bankruptcy

26Stays on appeal

He paid the damages and froze the fee award

Quiles v. Parent (2017) 10 Cal.App.5th 130 · California Court of Appeal

What happened

A plaintiff won a jury verdict. After post-trial motions the judgment was $208,500 in damages, about $689,000 in attorney fees, and about $50,600 in costs. The defendant paid the damages with interest and appealed only the fee and cost awards. He posted no bond. The plaintiff kept collecting: a writ of execution, a bank levy, a motion for a receiver and a charging order. The trial court refused to stop her.

What the court decided

The Court of Appeal did stop her. The basic rule favors creditors: an appeal does not stay a money judgment unless the debtor posts an undertaking, generally at least one and a half times the judgment, costs included. But a judgment solely for costs is stayed automatically by an appeal. Once the damages were paid, all that remained were fees and costs, which counted as costs under the statute. The creditor’s fallback was to ask the trial court to require a bond as a matter of discretion.

DoIf the debtor appeals without a bond, keep enforcing. If only a fee or cost award is on appeal, ask the trial court to require an undertaking.
Don’tDon’t assume a notice of appeal stops collection, and don’t assume it never does. Look at what part of the judgment is still unpaid.

Payments and satisfaction

27Partial payments

The check marked “full and complete satisfaction”

Lucky United Properties Investment, Inc. v. Lee (2013) 213 Cal.App.4th 635 · California Court of Appeal

What happened

A lawyer held a series of fee and cost awards against a former opponent. The debtor paid them one at a time. One check, for $33,830, came with a letter saying it was “tendered in full and complete satisfaction” and could not be applied to anything else. The creditor disputed that it was enough, but deposited it. The debtor then demanded an acknowledgment of satisfaction. The trial court ordered satisfaction entered and penalized the creditor for refusing.

What the court decided

As this opinion recounts, the Court of Appeal had reversed that order in an earlier appeal. The check did not cover accrued interest, and depositing it did not amount to an agreement to accept less. An earlier payment had also fallen short, because the judgment included small cost awards the debtor left out. The rule the court applied: a payment on a judgment goes first to accrued interest and then to principal. In 2013 the court recalculated the balance on that basis.

DoKeep a running ledger: each payment, the interest accrued to that date, and the new principal. Answer a demand for satisfaction in writing, with the numbers.
Don’tDon’t sign an acknowledgment of full satisfaction until interest and allowed costs are paid. Don’t ignore a demand either.
28Tender

The landlords who would not cash the checks

Rose v. Hecht (1949) 94 Cal.App.2d 662 · California Court of Appeal

What happened

Hotel owners refused to recognize the people running the hotel as their tenants under an assigned lease. The occupants sent rent checks, then cashier’s checks, then offered cash. The owners sent the money back, filed six lawsuits for the rent, and attached the occupants’ bank accounts. They eventually won judgments for the rent, with interest at seven percent added.

What the court decided

The Court of Appeal struck the interest. An offer of payment stops interest from running on the obligation. A creditor who refuses a tender without objecting to its form waives objections to the form. The court added that the same holds after judgment: a valid tender of the full judgment and costs, made while the creditor’s own appeal is pending, stops interest from that moment.

DoIf the debtor offers the full amount due, take it, or state in writing exactly what is missing. Then decide about any appeal.
Don’tDon’t refuse a full payment to keep interest running, or to gain leverage on another dispute. Interest can stop the day you say no.

Judgments from somewhere else

29Sister-state judgments

Seventeen months was too long to wait

Conseco Marketing, LLC v. IFA & Insurance Services, Inc. (2013) 221 Cal.App.4th 831 · California Court of Appeal

What happened

A creditor won a default judgment of about $675,000 in Indiana against two California companies. It filed an application in Los Angeles to enter a California judgment on the Indiana one. The clerk entered it ten days later, with no hearing. A process server delivered notice of entry to the companies’ registered agent. Seventeen months later the companies moved to vacate, saying they had not been served, had learned of the cases only later, and that the creditor was not registered to do business in California.

What the court decided

The motion was denied as untimely, and the Court of Appeal affirmed. A debtor has 30 days after service of the notice of entry to move to vacate. Service on the designated agent started that clock, whenever the companies themselves learned of it. A creditor from another state does not have to qualify to do business in California to use the procedure. The court noted one limit: the 30 days do not protect a judgment that is void because the debtor was never properly served in the original case.

DoServe the notice of entry promptly and in the same way a summons is served. File proof of service. Before you start, confirm the debtor was properly served in the original case.
Don’tDon’t levy on a sister-state judgment before it has been entered in California and the waiting period after service has passed.

FAQ

Keeping it alive

How long do I have to collect a California judgment?

Ten years from the date of entry, and another ten each time you renew. Family law judgments and judgments against public entities follow different rules. Do not wait for year nine. If the application is rejected for an error, you need time to fix it.

Law:Code Civ. Proc. §§ 683.020, 683.110–683.130.

I renewed the judgment. Is my lien on the debtor’s house still good?

Only if you also recorded a certified copy of the renewal application with the county recorder before the lien expired. Renewal of the judgment and extension of the lien are separate steps.

Law:Code Civ. Proc. § 683.180.

I bought (or was assigned) a judgment. Can I enforce it?

Yes, once you are the assignee of record. That means filing an acknowledgment of assignment of judgment with the court that entered it. Give the debtor written notice too, so that payments to the old creditor stop counting.

Law:Code Civ. Proc. §§ 673, 681.020.

The debtor paid. What do I have to do?

File an acknowledgment of satisfaction of judgment with the court once the judgment is paid in full, and release your liens. If the debtor sends a written demand and you do not comply within 15 days without good reason, you can owe damages, a $100 penalty, and the debtor’s attorney fees.

Law:Code Civ. Proc. §§ 724.030, 724.050, 724.080.

I have a judgment from another state. Do I have to sue all over again?

No. For a money judgment you file an application and the clerk enters a California judgment. You serve notice, the debtor has 30 days to move to vacate, and then it is enforced like any California judgment.

Law:Code Civ. Proc. §§ 1710.10–1710.65; Conseco Marketing, LLC v. IFA & Insurance Services, Inc. (2013) 221 Cal.App.4th 831.

What about a judgment from another country, or from a federal court?

A foreign-country money judgment is not registered. You file a lawsuit asking a California court to recognize it, and the debtor may raise the defenses the statute lists. A federal judgment from another district can be registered in a California federal court. Federal judgments are generally enforced with California’s procedures.

Law:Code Civ. Proc. §§ 1713–1725; 28 U.S.C. § 1963; Fed. Rules Civ. Proc., rule 69.

Published court decisions involving other parties, summarized for educational purposes. Benjy Law Corporation was not involved in these cases. Facts are as described in the courts’ opinions. A decision states a legal rule; it does not predict how any other matter will turn out.

(310) 203-2650

Statewide California.