The debtor’s cross-complaint did not stop the attachment
Lydig Construction, Inc. v. Martinez Steel Corp. (2015) 234 Cal.App.4th 937 · California Court of Appeal
What happened
A general contractor on a county jail project sued its steel subcontractor for more than $200,000. Its evidence: the subcontractor could not buy steel, could not post its bonds, and had diverted 100,000 pounds of the contractor’s steel to other jobs. The contractor asked for a writ of attachment and backed the request with business records and employee declarations. The subcontractor answered with a one-employee declaration and, on the day of the hearing, a cross-complaint claiming it was owed more than it owed.
What the court decided
The trial court attached $203,315 and the Court of Appeal affirmed. A cross-complaint reduces an attachment only if the debtor’s own claim is one that could support an attachment, and that means the debtor must show its claim is probably valid. A bare statement that the debtor “will vehemently dispute” the numbers at trial was not evidence. The contractor’s accounting records and delivery log were.