“Unknown” was not true, and the lien was void
Keele v. Reich (1985) 169 Cal.App.3d 1129 · California Court of Appeal
What happened
A creditor won a money judgment in May 1981 and recorded an abstract of judgment that October. The form asked for the debtor’s Social Security and driver’s license numbers. The creditor marked both “unknown,” although the Social Security number appeared in an exhibit to her own verified complaint. After the abstract was recorded, the debtor transferred his interest in a property to his wife in their divorce. She sued for a declaration that the lien was invalid.
What the court decided
She won on appeal. The statute said the abstract “shall” contain the number if the creditor knows it. Leaving out required information that the creditor had, or could immediately get, nullified the abstract. It did not matter that no one was actually confused about who the debtor was. The question is whether the abstract complied with the statute, and the cases that excuse minor defects all involved abstracts that contained every required item.
Since this case: the statute now lets a creditor record an amendment to add a missing number, with priority back to the original recording date, except against a buyer or lender who took an interest in between without actual notice (Code Civ. Proc., § 674, subd. (b)).