BENJY LAW CORPORATION

Lender Resources · Free guide

War stories
from the loan file

Real California court cases on commercial loans, told in plain English: how lenders papered them, enforced them, and defended them; where one avoidable choice cost the deficiency, the guaranty, or the interest; and what to do differently on your next loan.

Download the guide PDF · 63 pages · 2.2 MB · Free, no sign-up

General information about California law, not legal advice. Reading this does not create an attorney-client relationship.

32Real cases
6Lessons
30Questions answered
5Parts

What’s inside

5 short parts. Each one stands on its own and ends with a Take-Away. Every part is also on this site: read it online.

  1. IPapering the loanUsury and its exemptions, late charges and default interest, prepayment, compounding, and what the paper can and cannot do.Stories 01–07
  2. IIGuaranties: the second way to get paidWhy a guaranty stands on its own, how a foreclosure choice can release a guarantor, sham guaranties, and the limits of waivers.Stories 08–13
  3. IIIWorkouts, modifications and forbearanceLate payments, side promises, and workout paper: how lenders change a loan on purpose, and how they change it by accident.Stories 14–19
  4. IVDefault: choosing the remedyThe one-action rule, trustee’s sales, deficiencies, and the first move that can cost you the collateral.Stories 20–26
  5. VWhen the borrower suesInjunctions, wrongful foreclosure, lender-liability claims, and usury used as a weapon.Stories 27–32

Three stories from the guide

Every war story follows the same pattern: what happened, what the court decided, and what to do and not do.

War Story 01Usury: broker exemption

The broker only filled in the blanks

Gibbo v. Berger (2004) 123 Cal.App.4th 396 · California Court of Appeal

What happened

In 1992 a private lender made a $15,000 loan at 15 percent, secured by a deed of trust on the borrowers’ home. An escrow company owned by a licensed real estate broker typed the agreed terms into preprinted forms, ordered title insurance, and paid out the money, for a $100 fee. The borrowers made monthly interest payments over ten years. When the lender’s daughter started foreclosure to collect the principal, the borrower sued for usury. The lender’s side answered that the loan was exempt because a licensed broker had “arranged” it.

What the court decided

The Court of Appeal reversed a judgment for the lender. To “arrange” a loan, a broker must act as an intermediary who causes the loan to be made, for example by structuring it, setting the rate, or drafting its terms. This broker did none of that. She acted like “a scribe.” With no exemption, 15 percent was usurious. The lender was entitled to principal only, and the borrowers’ payments had already exceeded it, so the debt was satisfied and the deed of trust had to come off.

DoIf you rely on the broker exemption, have a licensed broker actually negotiate or structure the loan, be paid for it, and put that role in the file.
Don’tDon’t assume a broker’s license somewhere in the transaction, such as at the escrow company, makes the loan exempt.

War Story 08Independent obligation

The guarantor’s promise stood on its own

Bank of America v. Hunter (1937) 8 Cal.2d 592 · California Supreme Court

What happened

A woman guaranteed up to $4,300 of a $10,800 note that was secured by a deed of trust. The note went unpaid. The bank held a trustee’s sale, bought the land, and applied its bid to the debt. A balance equal to the guaranty remained. The bank sued her more than four years after the note came due, and more than three months after the sale. The trial court ended the case at the close of the evidence. Among her arguments: the new three-month deadline for suing after a trustee’s sale had passed.

What the court decided

The California Supreme Court reversed. The three-month deadline was written for a deficiency action on the secured debt itself. It did not apply to an action on “the independent obligation of a guarantor.” Two financial statements she gave the bank, which listed the guaranty as a liability, and a letter she wrote about it, were written acknowledgments that kept the four-year period alive. And the sale proceeds credited to the note did not use up her capped, continuing guaranty.

DoCollect a signed financial statement from each guarantor every year, and make sure it lists the guaranty as a liability.
Don’tDon’t treat the guaranty as an afterthought to the foreclosure. It is a separate contract with its own clock, and the clock runs.

War Story 14Waiver

A year of short payments did not rewrite the note

Hunt v. Smyth (1972) 25 Cal.App.3d 807 · California Court of Appeal

What happened

A note secured by a second deed of trust called for payments of $250 a month, rising to $350 in January 1968. The borrowers kept paying $250, often late. The holder took the money for more than a year without objecting to the amount. In March 1969 he wrote that he would accept nothing less than the full $350 going forward and gave a date to catch up. The borrowers kept sending $250 checks. He recorded a notice of default and returned the checks. The borrowers sued to stop the sale, claiming the note had been changed to $250.

What the court decided

The Court of Appeal sided with the note holder. Simply accepting part of what is due does not discharge the rest or change the payment terms. A modification or novation needs an agreement and consideration, and the borrowers had to prove it. Whatever leniency the holder had shown ended with his written demand. After that letter the short payments were not enough to cure the default.

DoWhen you decide the leniency is over, say so in a dated letter: the exact amount due, the date it is due, and that you will insist on the loan terms from then on.
Don’tDon’t go straight from months of accepting short payments to a notice of default. Give the written warning first.

Published court decisions involving other parties, summarized for educational purposes. Benjy Law Corporation was not involved in these cases. Facts are as described in the courts’ opinions. A decision states a legal rule; it does not predict how any other matter will turn out.

Read all 32 storiesPlus a ten-step checklist, a deadline chart, and a plain-English glossary.

Download the PDF
(310) 203-2650

Statewide California.