The guarantor’s promise stood on its own
Bank of America v. Hunter (1937) 8 Cal.2d 592 · California Supreme Court
What happened
A woman guaranteed up to $4,300 of a $10,800 note that was secured by a deed of trust. The note went unpaid. The bank held a trustee’s sale, bought the land, and applied its bid to the debt. A balance equal to the guaranty remained. The bank sued her more than four years after the note came due, and more than three months after the sale. The trial court ended the case at the close of the evidence. Among her arguments: the new three-month deadline for suing after a trustee’s sale had passed.
What the court decided
The California Supreme Court reversed. The three-month deadline was written for a deficiency action on the secured debt itself. It did not apply to an action on “the independent obligation of a guarantor.” Two financial statements she gave the bank, which listed the guaranty as a liability, and a letter she wrote about it, were written acknowledgments that kept the four-year period alive. And the sale proceeds credited to the note did not use up her capped, continuing guaranty.
Still the rule: the fair-value limits that apply to a borrower after a trustee’s sale do not apply to a true guarantor. Talbott v. Hustwit (2008) 164 Cal.App.4th 148. See also Code Civ. Proc. § 580d(b).