BENJY LAW CORPORATION

Lender Resources · Part II of V

Guaranties: the second way to get paid

A guaranty is often the only way to collect a shortfall after a trustee’s sale. Real cases on what makes a guaranty enforceable, the waivers it must contain, and the three ways lenders have lost one: a sham structure, their own conduct, and an illegal loan.

6 war storiesCalifornia lawFrom War Stories from the Loan File

Talk to a lawyer: (310) 203-2650

General information about California law, not legal advice. Reading this does not create an attorney-client relationship.

In this part · 6 war stories
  1. 08The guarantor’s promise stood on its own
  2. 09The trustee’s sale that released the guarantor
  3. 10The bank’s lawyer asked for a new borrower
  4. 11The borrowers picked the entity, so the guaranties held
  5. 12The waivers did not cover the bank’s own misconduct
  6. 13The guarantors raised usury, and their waiver did not stop them
Lender FAQ →

In California, a lender that forecloses by trustee’s sale usually cannot collect the shortfall from the borrower. A guaranty is the main exception. A true guarantor can be sued for the deficiency, and can agree in advance to give up most of the defenses a guarantor would otherwise have.

That makes the guaranty the most valuable page in many loan files, and the most attacked. Guarantors defend these cases in three ways. They say they were really the borrower. They say the lender’s own conduct released them. Or they say the loan itself was illegal. Each of those has worked at least once.

A separate promise, with its own rules

08Independent obligation

The guarantor’s promise stood on its own

Bank of America v. Hunter (1937) 8 Cal.2d 592 · California Supreme Court

What happened

A woman guaranteed up to $4,300 of a $10,800 note that was secured by a deed of trust. The note went unpaid. The bank held a trustee’s sale, bought the land, and applied its bid to the debt. A balance equal to the guaranty remained. The bank sued her more than four years after the note came due, and more than three months after the sale. The trial court ended the case at the close of the evidence. Among her arguments: the new three-month deadline for suing after a trustee’s sale had passed.

What the court decided

The California Supreme Court reversed. The three-month deadline was written for a deficiency action on the secured debt itself. It did not apply to an action on “the independent obligation of a guarantor.” Two financial statements she gave the bank, which listed the guaranty as a liability, and a letter she wrote about it, were written acknowledgments that kept the four-year period alive. And the sale proceeds credited to the note did not use up her capped, continuing guaranty.

DoCollect a signed financial statement from each guarantor every year, and make sure it lists the guaranty as a liability.
Don’tDon’t treat the guaranty as an afterthought to the foreclosure. It is a separate contract with its own clock, and the clock runs.

Still the rule: the fair-value limits that apply to a borrower after a trustee’s sale do not apply to a true guarantor. Talbott v. Hustwit (2008) 164 Cal.App.4th 148. See also Code Civ. Proc. § 580d(b).

09Election of remedies

The trustee’s sale that released the guarantor

Union Bank v. Gradsky (1968) 265 Cal.App.2d 40 · California Court of Appeal

What happened

A bank made a $112,500 construction loan to a property owner, secured by a first deed of trust. The general contractor signed a guaranty. In it he waived any right to require the bank to go after the borrower first, to apply its security, or “to pursue any other remedy.” The loan was not paid. The bank chose a trustee’s sale and bought the property. That left $11,565.97 unpaid, and the bank sued the guarantor for it. The trial court dismissed the case.

What the court decided

The Court of Appeal affirmed. The rule against deficiency judgments after a trustee’s sale does not protect a guarantor directly. But a guarantor who pays is entitled to step into the lender’s shoes and recover from the borrower. By choosing a trustee’s sale, the bank wiped out that right, because nobody can get a deficiency from the borrower after such a sale. Having destroyed the guarantor’s recourse by its own choice, the bank could not collect from him. The defense can be waived, the court said, but only explicitly. The general waiver in this guaranty was not enough.

DoBefore any trustee’s sale on a guaranteed loan, have counsel read the guaranty’s waivers. If they are weak, sue the guarantor first or foreclose in court.
Don’tDon’t assume “the guarantor waived everything.” This guarantor had waived the bank’s duty to pursue “any other remedy,” and still won.

Since then: Civ. Code § 2856 now lets a guarantor waive this defense, and supplies wording that is sufficient. Check that every guaranty in your files has it.

True guarantor, or borrower in disguise?

10Sham guaranty

The bank’s lawyer asked for a new borrower

River Bank America v. Diller (1995) 38 Cal.App.4th 1400 · California Court of Appeal

What happened

A bank lent $38 million to build an apartment complex. The notes were nonrecourse. The developer, his wife, their family trust, and their development company guaranteed 20 percent. After default, the bank sued, held a trustee’s sale that came up $12.9 million short, and pursued the guaranties. According to the developer’s sworn statement, the bank’s lawyer had insisted that the borrower be a new limited partnership whose general partner was not the development company, so the guaranty would be “enforceable,” and a shell corporation was put in that role. He also said the bank reviewed only the guarantors’ finances and never asked about the shell’s.

What the court decided

The result was mixed. The guarantors’ written waivers defeated their argument that they could not owe more than the nonrecourse borrower. But on that evidence, the bank could not win without a trial on whether the guaranties were shams. A guarantor is someone who answers for the debt of another. If a lender structures the deal so that the real borrower signs as “guarantor,” that person keeps the borrower’s protection against deficiency judgments, and that protection cannot be waived.

DoLet the borrower and its advisers choose the borrowing entity, and underwrite that entity, not only the people behind it.
Don’tDon’t ask for a shell borrower to be inserted so that the principals can sign as guarantors. That request became the guarantors’ best evidence.
11Sham guaranty

The borrowers picked the entity, so the guaranties held

CADC/RADC Venture 2011-1 LLC v. Bradley (2015) 235 Cal.App.4th 775 · California Court of Appeal

What happened

Two investors arranged a $2.1 million loan to buy land in Napa. Their corporation applied for the loan. Two days before closing, on their tax adviser’s advice, they switched the borrower to a new limited liability company, for tax reasons tied to a tax-deferred exchange. The bank did not ask for the change. Both men signed guaranties that waived the antideficiency protections. After default and a trustee’s sale, about $1.3 million was still owed. A jury found the guaranties were shams.

What the court decided

The Court of Appeal reversed and ordered judgment for the lender. A guaranty is a sham when the guarantor is really the primary obligor, or when the lender structures the loan to get around the antideficiency laws. Neither was shown. The guarantors never owned the borrower directly, their corporation observed its formalities and kept separate accounts, and the structure was their idea, chosen for their own tax benefit. People who take the benefits of borrowing through an entity take the risks too.

DoKeep the emails showing who proposed the borrowing structure and why. In this case that record mattered on appeal.
Don’tDon’t skip the borrower’s own financials. The guarantors argued the bank looked only to them, and the court took the argument seriously.
Facts courts have weighed in sham-guaranty cases
QuestionPoints toward a true guarantyPoints toward a sham
Who chose the borrowing entity?The borrower, for its own tax or business reasons (Bradley)The lender or its lawyer, to make a guaranty “enforceable” (as alleged in Diller)
Is the guarantor already liable for the borrower’s debt?No. A separate entity stands between them and observes its formalitiesYes, for example a general partner guaranteeing the partnership’s note
Whose finances did the lender review?The borrower’s, or its parent’s, as well as the guarantor’sOnly the guarantor’s, with a shell as the borrower
What does the guaranty itself say?Express waivers that track Civ. Code § 2856Waivers do not matter if the signer is really the borrower

What a waiver cannot fix

12Limits of waivers

The waivers did not cover the bank’s own misconduct

California Bank & Trust v. DelPonti (2014) 232 Cal.App.4th 162 · California Court of Appeal

What happened

A bank made a construction loan for a 70-unit townhome project. The developer’s two principals signed guaranties with broad waivers. For 18 months the project stayed on schedule. Then, with the first phase nearly done, the bank stopped funding payment applications it had already approved. Units could not be finished or sold, and the loan went into default. The bank later foreclosed. Its successor sued the guarantors for the deficiency and argued that they had waived every defense.

What the court decided

The guarantors won at trial and on appeal. The trial court found the bank had materially breached the loan agreement and was guilty of willful misconduct, and the bank did not challenge those findings. The Court of Appeal held that a guarantor’s advance waivers reach the legal and statutory defenses set out in the guaranty. They are read strictly. They do not waive equitable defenses such as unclean hands when enforcement would let the lender profit from its own fraud or willful misconduct.

DoFund approved draws, or document a contractual reason for stopping, before you rely on a guaranty.
Don’tDon’t treat a guaranty’s waiver section as protection against your own breach of the loan agreement.
13Illegality

The guarantors raised usury, and their waiver did not stop them

WRI Opportunity Loans II LLC v. Cooper (2007) 154 Cal.App.4th 525 · California Court of Appeal

What happened

A junior lender lent about $2.5 million, later increased to $3.2 million, to a company developing townhouses and condominiums. On top of the stated rate, the loan called for “additional interest”: a percentage of each unit’s sale price, with a schedule that paid the lender a set amount even if units were never built. The lender’s own analysis projected a return of about 38 percent. The company’s two principals guaranteed the loan and waived their defenses. When the lender sued them, the trial court entered a $6.6 million judgment without a trial.

What the court decided

The Court of Appeal reversed. The lender argued the loan was an exempt shared-appreciation loan. It was not, because the extra interest was guaranteed, not at risk and not a true share of appreciation. And the guarantors could raise usury despite their waivers. The usurious part of a loan is illegal, a guarantor cannot waive illegality in advance, and Civil Code section 2856 did not change that. The court did not decide that the loan was usurious. It sent the case back with that defense still to be resolved.

DoRun the usury analysis on the loan as if the guarantor will be the one raising it, because the guarantor can.
Don’tDon’t rely on a guaranty to rescue interest the borrower could not legally be charged.

FAQ

Guaranties

After a trustee’s sale, can we still sue the guarantor for the shortfall?

Yes, if the guarantor is a true guarantor and the guaranty contains the waivers the statute allows. The bar on deficiencies after a trustee’s sale does not by its terms affect a guarantor’s liability. Without an election-of-remedies waiver, though, the sale itself can release the guarantor.

Law:Code Civ. Proc. § 580d(b); Civ. Code § 2856; Union Bank v. Gradsky (1968) 265 Cal.App.2d 40.

Can the owners of our LLC borrower sign as guarantors?

Yes. That is the usual arrangement, and courts enforce it when the entity is real and separate. The risk is a guarantor who is already liable for the borrower’s debt, or a structure the lender imposed to get around the antideficiency rules.

Law:CADC/RADC Venture 2011-1 LLC v. Bradley (2015) 235 Cal.App.4th 775; River Bank America v. Diller (1995) 38 Cal.App.4th 1400.

Does a guaranty need its own consideration?

Not when it is signed along with the loan and is part of what the lender bargained for. A written guaranty is also presumed to be supported by consideration, and the guarantor has the burden of showing otherwise. A guaranty added later should recite what the lender gave for it, such as an extension or new money.

Law:Civ. Code §§ 2792, 1614, 1615; Glickman v. Collins (1975) 13 Cal.3d 852.

How long do we have to sue a guarantor?

Generally four years on a written guaranty. The three-month deadline for a deficiency action after a trustee’s sale applies to the secured debt, not to a guarantor’s independent promise. Do not wait: guarantors’ assets move.

Law:Code Civ. Proc. § 337(a); Bank of America v. Hunter (1937) 8 Cal.2d 592.

Our guaranty says the guarantor “waives all defenses.” Is that enough?

No. Advance waivers are read strictly and reach the legal and statutory defenses the guaranty identifies. They do not cover the lender’s own fraud or willful misconduct, and they do not cover illegality, such as a usurious loan.

Law:California Bank & Trust v. DelPonti (2014) 232 Cal.App.4th 162; WRI Opportunity Loans II LLC v. Cooper (2007) 154 Cal.App.4th 525.

Should the guarantor’s spouse sign too?

Ask your lawyer before closing, not at collection. Which marital property a guaranty can reach, and whether a spouse’s signature or consent is needed, depends on how the couple holds title and on the collateral. It is far cheaper to settle the question at closing than to litigate it later.

Published court decisions involving other parties, summarized for educational purposes. Benjy Law Corporation was not involved in these cases. Facts are as described in the courts’ opinions. A decision states a legal rule; it does not predict how any other matter will turn out.

(310) 203-2650

Statewide California.