BENJY LAW CORPORATION

Lender Resources · Part I of V

Papering the loan

Most loan losses in court start at the closing table. Real cases on usury exemptions, late charges, default interest, prepayment fees, compound interest, and why a signed integration clause does not shut out a fraud claim.

7 war storiesCalifornia lawFrom War Stories from the Loan File

Talk to a lawyer: (310) 203-2650

General information about California law, not legal advice. Reading this does not create an attorney-client relationship.

In this part · 7 war stories
  1. 01The broker only filled in the blanks
  2. 02The broker’s own company made the loan, and the exemption held
  3. 03A $100,000 fee “added to principal”
  4. 04One missed payment raised the rate on the whole balance
  5. 05A prepayment fee that was really a late fee
  6. 06The note said “thereafter,” so compounding started eleven years late
  7. 07“It’s a two-year extension. Just sign at the tabs.”
Lender FAQ →

A loan is only as good as its paper. When a borrower stops paying, the first thing the borrower’s lawyer does is read your note, line by line, looking for the clause a court will not enforce.

This part is about the clauses that get attacked most: the interest rate, the late charge, the default rate, the prepayment fee, and the compounding language. In most of these stories the lender’s money was real and the borrower’s default was real. The lender still lost something, because of how one sentence was written or who did the work at closing.

Interest and the usury trap

01Usury: broker exemption

The broker only filled in the blanks

Gibbo v. Berger (2004) 123 Cal.App.4th 396 · California Court of Appeal

What happened

In 1992 a private lender made a $15,000 loan at 15 percent, secured by a deed of trust on the borrowers’ home. An escrow company owned by a licensed real estate broker typed the agreed terms into preprinted forms, ordered title insurance, and paid out the money, for a $100 fee. The borrowers made monthly interest payments over ten years. When the lender’s daughter started foreclosure to collect the principal, the borrower sued for usury. The lender’s side answered that the loan was exempt because a licensed broker had “arranged” it.

What the court decided

The Court of Appeal reversed a judgment for the lender. To “arrange” a loan, a broker must act as an intermediary who causes the loan to be made, for example by structuring it, setting the rate, or drafting its terms. This broker did none of that. She acted like “a scribe.” With no exemption, 15 percent was usurious. The lender was entitled to principal only, and the borrowers’ payments had already exceeded it, so the debt was satisfied and the deed of trust had to come off.

DoIf you rely on the broker exemption, have a licensed broker actually negotiate or structure the loan, be paid for it, and put that role in the file.
Don’tDon’t assume a broker’s license somewhere in the transaction, such as at the escrow company, makes the loan exempt.
02Usury: broker exemption

The broker’s own company made the loan, and the exemption held

Bock v. California Capital Loans, Inc. (2013) 216 Cal.App.4th 264 · California Court of Appeal

What happened

The trustee of a family trust needed a loan. A third party put him in touch with a licensed real estate broker who was also the sole shareholder of a lending company. The broker told the borrower the terms and prepared the disclosure statements. His company lent $1.2 million at 15 percent, secured by a deed of trust. He took no commission. The borrower defaulted, the lender foreclosed and bought the property at the trustee’s sale, and the borrower sued, claiming the rate was usurious and the sale was void.

What the court decided

The lender won at trial and on appeal. The court held that a broker can arrange a loan “for another” even when the lender is a corporation he wholly owns, and that the profit his company expected from the interest can count as acting “in expectation of compensation.” The evidence supported the finding that the broker acted in his own licensed capacity. The court contrasted an earlier case where the evidence showed licensed individuals were acting for an unlicensed company, and the exemption was lost.

DoBe able to prove, with documents, which licensed person arranged the loan and in what capacity: disclosures, correspondence, and the license number.
Don’tDon’t leave the exemption to be reconstructed years later from memory. Build the proof into the closing file.
03Usury: what counts as a loan

A $100,000 fee “added to principal”

Ghirardo v. Antonioli (1994) 8 Cal.4th 791 · California Supreme Court

What happened

Sellers of land took back a note and deed of trust. A later buyer took the property subject to that debt. A payment dispute led to a foreclosure notice, a lawsuit, and then a settlement: the sellers cancelled the old note, and the buyer paid cash and signed two new notes. One note was at 13 percent. The other stated 10 percent, but a $100,000 fee was added to its principal, which made the effective rate 17.46 percent when the limit was 10.5 percent. The buyer paid, then sued for usury. The trial court ordered the sellers to give back the interest.

What the court decided

The California Supreme Court reversed. Usury requires a loan or a forbearance. This was a seller’s restructuring of a credit sale, which is not a loan, and the restructuring kept that status. The court also restated the ground rules. The borrower must prove usury. But the only intent required is the intent to take the interest actually charged, and courts look at the substance of a deal, not its labels.

DoBefore closing, and before every modification, compute the effective rate with every fee, point, bonus, and discount counted.
Don’tDon’t read this case as cover for a money loan. The sellers won because they were sellers. A lender of money that adds a fee to principal is charging interest.

Late charges, default interest, and prepayment fees

04Default interest

One missed payment raised the rate on the whole balance

Honchariw v. FJM Private Mortgage Fund, LLC (2022) 83 Cal.App.5th 893 · California Court of Appeal

What happened

Borrowers took a $5.6 million bridge loan at 8.5 percent, secured by a first deed of trust. They missed one monthly payment of $39,667. The note then imposed two charges: a one-time fee of 10 percent of the late payment, and default interest of 9.99 percent a year, on top of the note rate, on the entire unpaid principal until the default was cured. The note recited that the lender’s losses from a default would be hard to estimate. An arbitrator upheld the charges, and the trial court refused to set the award aside.

What the court decided

The Court of Appeal reversed. A charge for a late installment that is measured against the whole unpaid balance, most of which is not yet due, is an unlawful penalty. A recital in the note plus a one-word “Yes” from the lender’s principal did not show a real effort to estimate the lender’s loss. The court drew a line: the borrower here defaulted on a loan that had not matured. It distinguished cases where default interest began only when the whole loan came due.

DoTie a late charge to the late payment. If you want a default rate before maturity, be ready to show how the number relates to your actual cost of a default.
Don’tDon’t count on a “the parties agree this is reasonable” clause to carry a default rate that applies to the full balance after one missed installment.
05Prepayment charge

A prepayment fee that was really a late fee

Ridgley v. Topa Thrift & Loan Assn. (1998) 17 Cal.4th 970 · California Supreme Court

What happened

A developer borrowed $2.3 million for two years as a bridge loan on a house he had built to sell. The lender’s form charged six months’ interest on any prepayment. The developer objected, so the lender added a sentence: no prepayment charge after the first six months, provided every payment had arrived no more than 15 days late and there had been no other default. One interest payment came in late. When the house sold and the loan was paid off, the lender demanded a prepayment charge of about $113,000.

What the court decided

The California Supreme Court held the charge was an unenforceable penalty. A true prepayment charge is lawful, because paying early is the borrower’s choice and not a breach. But this charge, after month six, applied only if the borrower had paid late. In substance it punished late payment, and six months’ interest on the whole principal bore no reasonable relationship to the harm caused by one late interest payment. The court refused to save it by calling it a “conditional waiver.”

DoKeep the prepayment charge and the late charge in separate clauses, each priced for the loss it covers.
Don’tDon’t offer to waive a fee “if the borrower is never late.” A court will treat the fee as a late charge and test it as a penalty.

What the paper says, and what was said out loud

06Compound interest

The note said “thereafter,” so compounding started eleven years late

Curry v. Moody (1995) 40 Cal.App.4th 1547 · California Court of Appeal

What happened

In 1981 a couple lent a homeowner $19,200. The note called for 13 percent interest, “payable at the time of sale of the house,” and added: “Should interest not be so paid it shall thereafter bear like interest as the principal.” The loan was never repaid. In 1992 the house was sold at another lender’s foreclosure sale. In later litigation, the lenders claimed compound interest from 1981, and offered evidence that they and the borrower had always intended that. The trial court agreed.

What the court decided

The Court of Appeal cut the award back. The note gave simple interest until the house was sold in August 1992, and compound interest only “thereafter.” California law does not allow interest on interest unless an agreement to that effect is clearly expressed in a writing signed by the borrower. So testimony about what the parties meant could not fill the gap. An unclear note is read as simple interest.

DoIf you intend interest to compound, say so in the note in plain words: what compounds, how often, and starting when.
Don’tDon’t rely on a boilerplate sentence, or on what everyone understood, to turn unpaid interest into principal.

Also: For lenders exempt from the usury limits, the California Supreme Court has held that the old usury statute’s compound-interest rule and its penalties do not apply, but an exempt lender still needs a contractual or legal basis to compound. Wishnev v. Northwestern Mutual Life Ins. Co. (2019) 8 Cal.5th 199.

07Oral promises and fraud

“It’s a two-year extension. Just sign at the tabs.”

Riverisland Cold Storage, Inc. v. Fresno-Madera Production Credit Assn. (2013) 55 Cal.4th 1169 · California Supreme Court

What happened

Borrowers fell behind and signed a restructuring agreement with their lender. The written agreement gave them about three months of forbearance and listed eight parcels as added collateral. The borrowers initialed the pages describing the parcels. They later sued for fraud. They said the lender’s vice president told them, two weeks earlier and again at signing, that the deal was a two-year extension secured by two ranches. They admitted they signed at the tabs without reading. The trial court threw the case out, ruling that the written agreement barred evidence of contrary oral promises.

What the court decided

The California Supreme Court let the fraud claims go forward and overruled a 1935 decision that lenders had relied on for decades. A written, integrated contract cannot be varied by earlier oral terms. But that rule was never meant to be a shield against proof of fraud. The court added that fraud still requires more than a broken promise, and that the borrower must show justifiable reliance. It left open whether these borrowers could show that after not reading what they signed.

DoSend the final terms in writing before signing, and have the loan officer confirm in an email what the documents say about term and collateral.
Don’tDon’t let anyone describe a workout in terms the documents do not match. The integration clause will not keep that testimony out.
MythWe make business loans, so usury does not apply to us.
RealityIt can. The constitutional cap covers business loans too, under its own formula. What takes a loan outside the cap is an exemption, so be ready to prove yours.
MythA licensed broker touched the file, so we are exempt.
RealityNot if the broker only prepared documents. The broker has to arrange the loan as an intermediary, for compensation (Gibbo).
MythThe borrower agreed in writing that our default rate is reasonable.
RealityA recital did not save a default rate charged on the whole balance after one missed installment (Honchariw).
MythOur integration clause blocks any claim about what the loan officer said.
RealityIt blocks attempts to add or change terms. It does not block a fraud claim (Riverisland).

FAQ

Papering the loan

We are a private lender. Does California’s usury cap apply to our business loans?

It applies unless the lender or the loan is exempt. The common exemptions for private lenders are a state lending license and a loan secured by real estate that a licensed real estate broker made or arranged. If neither applies, a business loan is capped at the higher of 10 percent or 5 points over the San Francisco Fed’s discount rate.

Law:Cal. Const., art. XV, § 1; Civ. Code § 1916.1; Fin. Code § 22002.

A broker arranged the original loan. Is our later extension or forbearance covered too?

The broker statute now speaks to this directly. As amended effective January 1, 2025, it covers a forbearance, extension, or modification of a real-estate-secured loan that a licensed broker makes or arranges. Have the broker involved in the modification itself, and document it. Cases decided before 2025 applied older wording.

Law:Civ. Code § 1916.1 (as amended by Stats. 2024, ch. 601).

Can we charge a higher default rate?

After the loan matures, courts have treated default interest differently from a penalty. Before maturity, a default rate applied to the whole balance because of one missed installment was held to be an unlawful penalty. In between, expect to show that the rate reasonably relates to your cost of a default.

Law:Civ. Code § 1671(b); Honchariw v. FJM Private Mortgage Fund, LLC (2022) 83 Cal.App.5th 893.

If we accelerate after a default, can we still collect the prepayment charge?

Only if the note says so clearly. A court enforced a prepayment charge after acceleration where the clause expressly covered involuntary prepayment, including prepayment caused by the lender’s acceleration. Where the clause speaks only of the borrower’s privilege to prepay, expect a court to read it against the lender. And a charge that applies only because the borrower paid late, not because of the early payoff, is tested as a penalty.

Law:Pacific Trust Co. TTEE v. Fidelity Fed. Sav. & Loan Assn. (1986) 184 Cal.App.3d 817; Ridgley v. Topa Thrift & Loan Assn. (1998) 17 Cal.4th 970.

Can we charge interest on unpaid interest?

If you are not exempt from the usury law, only if the borrower signed a writing that clearly says so. If the note is unclear, it bears simple interest, and testimony about what the parties intended will not change that. An exempt lender is not bound by that statute, but it still needs a contractual or legal basis to compound, so write it into the note either way.

Law:Civ. Code § 1916-2; Curry v. Moody (1995) 40 Cal.App.4th 1547; Wishnev v. Northwestern Mutual Life Ins. Co. (2019) 8 Cal.5th 199.

The borrower sold the property without telling us. Can we call the loan?

If the deed of trust has a due-on-sale clause, generally yes. Federal law makes these clauses enforceable according to their terms and overrides older California limits. The federal exceptions are for certain transfers of homes with fewer than five units.

Law:12 U.S.C. § 1701j-3.

Published court decisions involving other parties, summarized for educational purposes. Benjy Law Corporation was not involved in these cases. Facts are as described in the courts’ opinions. A decision states a legal rule; it does not predict how any other matter will turn out.

(310) 203-2650

Statewide California.