BENJY LAW CORPORATION

Lender Resources · Part IV of V

Default: choosing the remedy

California makes a real estate lender choose its remedy carefully and in the right order. See how a $2,800 setoff cost a bank its deed of trust, when a lender can still sue after a trustee’s sale, and what a full credit bid gives away.

7 war storiesCalifornia lawFrom War Stories from the Loan File

Talk to a lawyer: (310) 203-2650

General information about California law, not legal advice. Reading this does not create an attorney-client relationship.

In this part · 7 war stories
  1. 20A $2,804 setoff cost the bank its deed of trust
  2. 21The bank sued on the equipment and lost the land
  3. 22A note secured by someone else’s land was not “real property security”
  4. 23A notice mailed a week early did not undo the sale
  5. 24They bid the full debt, and the insurance money was no longer theirs
  6. 25The junior lender wiped out by someone else’s sale could still sue
  7. 26One lender, two deeds of trust, and the junior note survived
Lender FAQ →

When a California loan is secured by real estate, the lender does not get to collect any way it likes. It must go to the real estate first, in one proceeding. And the way it forecloses decides whether it can ever collect the shortfall.

These rules punish the wrong first move. Lenders in this part lost a deed of trust over a few thousand dollars taken from a deposit account, and lost real estate collateral by suing on the equipment first. Others kept a deficiency claim that looked lost. The difference was the order in which they acted.

Security first, and only one action

20One-action rule

A $2,804 setoff cost the bank its deed of trust

Security Pacific National Bank v. Wozab (1990) 51 Cal.3d 991 · California Supreme Court

What happened

A company owed its bank more than $1 million on a credit line. The owners had guaranteed the debt and later gave the bank a deed of trust on their home to secure the guaranties. Worried about a bankruptcy, the bank swept the deposit accounts, including $2,804.82 from the owners’ personal accounts. The owners said the setoff had waived the deed of trust. The bank reconveyed it and sued on the guaranties for the remaining $976,000. The trial court ruled the bank had lost the debt too.

What the court decided

The California Supreme Court held that the setoff broke the security-first rule of Code Civ. Proc. § 726. A lender with real estate security may not help itself to the debtor’s deposit accounts first. The price was the security: the deed of trust was gone. But a divided court refused to wipe out the debt as well, calling that a penalty 300 times the amount of the setoff. The bank could sue as an unsecured creditor.

DoFlag every real-estate-secured loan in your deposit system so that no one can set off against that borrower’s or pledgor’s accounts without legal review.
Don’tDon’t sweep accounts, apply held funds, or grab other assets to pay down a loan secured by California real estate before you have foreclosed.

Note: the court left open what happens when a setoff is inadvertent and promptly returned. If it happens, reverse it immediately and call counsel.

21One-action rule

The bank sued on the equipment and lost the land

Walker v. Community Bank (1974) 10 Cal.3d 729 · California Supreme Court

What happened

A bank made one loan secured two ways: a chattel mortgage on the borrower’s equipment and trucks, and a deed of trust on real property. After default the bank filed a court action to foreclose on the equipment only. It sold the equipment and took a deficiency judgment of about $93,000. The real property was never mentioned in that case. The bank also started a trustee’s sale on the real property, which the borrower had by then sold to a new owner.

What the court decided

The new owner won, and the bank’s lien on the real property was gone. A lender gets one action on a debt secured by real property, and it must include all of the security. By taking a deficiency judgment without foreclosing on the land, the bank chose its remedy and waived the deed of trust, against everyone. It did not matter that the borrower never raised the rule in the first case.

DoList every piece of collateral securing the debt before you file anything, and have counsel map the order of enforcement.
Don’tDon’t take a money judgment against the borrower while real estate collateral for the same debt sits unforeclosed.

Note: the Commercial Code now lets a lender with both kinds of collateral proceed against the personal property and the real property in any sequence (Com. Code § 9604). But once a money judgment on the debt is entered in an action that left the real property out, the borrower may still assert that the deed of trust is unenforceable. That is what happened here.

22Pledged notes

A note secured by someone else’s land was not “real property security”

Bank of California v. Leone (1974) 37 Cal.App.3d 444 · California Court of Appeal

What happened

A borrower owed the bank on an unsecured $13,500 note. To get more time, he handed the bank, as collateral, a $17,600 note that a third party owed him. That third party’s note was secured by a fourth deed of trust on land. The borrower defaulted on his own renewed note. The bank sued him directly without first foreclosing on the pledged note or the land behind it. The borrower argued the one-action rule required the bank to go after the collateral first.

What the court decided

The Court of Appeal disagreed. The borrower’s own debt was secured by a note, which is personal property, not by a mortgage on real property. The one-action rule did not apply, and the bank could take a judgment on the borrower’s note without first enforcing the pledged paper.

DoKnow exactly what secures each obligation: a deed of trust on the obligor’s real estate, or a pledge of someone else’s paper. The enforcement rules differ.
Don’tDon’t assume this result if you later end up owning the land behind the pledged note. Get advice before you foreclose the underlying deed of trust.

The trustee’s sale

23Notice

A notice mailed a week early did not undo the sale

Knapp v. Doherty (2004) 123 Cal.App.4th 76 · California Court of Appeal

What happened

Homeowners defaulted and the lender’s trustee recorded a notice of default. The trustee mailed the notice of sale a few days before the three-month waiting period had run. The borrowers filed bankruptcy, the sale was postponed more than a dozen times, and it finally took place almost a year after the date first noticed. A third party bought the property. The borrowers then sued to set the sale aside, pointing to the early mailing and a low price.

What the court decided

The sale stood. The notice had gone out slightly early, but the borrowers received more than the required 20 days’ notice and did nothing to cure during the year the sale was pending. A minor procedural slip that causes no harm does not undo a trustee’s sale. Even a low price is not enough unless an irregularity contributed to it or otherwise hurt the borrower.

DoUse an experienced trustee, calendar every statutory date, and keep proof of each recording, mailing, posting, and publication.
Don’tDon’t count on a court to forgive a notice defect. This lender won because the borrowers could show no harm at all.

Note: this was a home loan, decided before later homeowner-protection statutes. The no-prejudice reasoning is the part that carries over to commercial loans.

24Full credit bid

They bid the full debt, and the insurance money was no longer theirs

Caruso v. Great Western Savings (1991) 229 Cal.App.3d 667 · California Court of Appeal

What happened

A house was badly damaged by land movement, and about $190,000 of insurance money sat in dispute between the owners and the senior lender. The junior lienholders foreclosed and took the property at their own trustee’s sale with a full credit bid of $131,580, the entire amount owed to them. Then they tried to block the senior lender’s foreclosure, arguing the insurance money should have been applied to shrink the senior debt.

What the court decided

They had no standing to make the argument. A full credit bid means the lender has been paid in full. Its debt is satisfied and its lien is extinguished, so it has no remaining claim to insurance proceeds or other recoveries tied to the debt. The senior lender also had a lesson: fees for carrying out a foreclosure are capped by statute, and only fees for protecting the security can be added to the debt under the loan documents. Its fee award of more than $32,000 was sent back to be sorted.

DoSet your credit bid deliberately. If you may still have insurance, rents, or damage claims to pursue, talk to counsel about bidding less than the full debt.
Don’tDon’t tell the trustee to “bid the debt” out of habit, and don’t lump foreclosure fees and protective legal fees into one number.
Two ways to foreclose in California
Trustee’s sale (nonjudicial)Court foreclosure (judicial)
How it worksThe trustee records a notice of default, waits the statutory period, gives notice of sale, and sells at public auction. No lawsuit is needed.The lender files a lawsuit, obtains a decree of foreclosure, and the property is sold under court supervision.
Deficiency against the borrowerBarred. No deficiency may be collected after a sale under the power of sale (Code Civ. Proc. § 580d).Available unless another rule bars it, but limited to the debt minus the property’s fair value, and the lender must apply for the fair-value hearing within 3 months of the sale (§ 726, subd. (b)).
Borrower’s right to redeem after the saleNone.Yes, if the lender keeps its right to a deficiency judgment. The property is then sold subject to a statutory right to redeem for a period after the sale (§ 726, subd. (e)). That is the trade-off for the deficiency.
Borrower’s right to reinstate before the saleUntil 5 business days before the sale date (Civ. Code § 2924c, subd. (e)).Until entry of the decree of foreclosure (Civ. Code § 2924c, subd. (a)(1)).
Guarantors and other collateralThe bar on a deficiency does not, by itself, release a guarantor or other pledged collateral (§ 580d, subd. (b)). See Part II.Guarantors can be joined in the action. See Part II.
Best suited toLoans where the property will cover the debt, or where speed and clean title matter more than the shortfall.Loans where the shortfall is large, the borrower can pay a judgment, and the time and cost of a lawsuit are worth it.

After the sale: who can still be sued

25Sold-out junior

The junior lender wiped out by someone else’s sale could still sue

Roseleaf Corp. v. Chierighino (1963) 59 Cal.2d 35 · California Supreme Court

What happened

A company sold its hotel and took, as part of the price, three notes secured by second deeds of trust on other parcels the buyer owned. Other lenders held the first deeds of trust on those parcels. They foreclosed by trustee’s sale. The seller’s second deeds of trust were wiped out and it received nothing. It sued the buyer on the three notes. The buyer said the antideficiency statutes barred the suit.

What the court decided

The California Supreme Court allowed the suit. A junior lender whose security is destroyed by a senior lender’s sale has nothing left to foreclose, so the one-action rule does not apply. The fair-value limits and the three-month deadline did not apply either, and § 580d did not bar the claim, because the junior never sold under its own deed of trust. The purchase-money bar did not apply because the land securing these notes was not the property being bought.

DoWhen a senior lender forecloses ahead of you, decide early whether to bid, to cure the senior loan, or to let the sale go and sue on your note.
Don’tDon’t assume a junior loan is worthless once the senior’s sale wipes out your lien. Have the note reviewed before you write it off.
26Two liens, one lender

One lender, two deeds of trust, and the junior note survived

Black Sky Capital, LLC v. Cobb (2019) 7 Cal.5th 156 · California Supreme Court

What happened

A bank made a $10.3 million loan secured by a first deed of trust on commercial property in Rancho Cucamonga. Two years later it made the same borrowers a separate $1.5 million loan secured by a second deed of trust on the same property. An investor bought both loans, foreclosed on the first by trustee’s sale, and acquired the property for $7.5 million. It then sued on the second note. The trial court held § 580d barred the suit because the same creditor held both liens.

What the court decided

The California Supreme Court disagreed. Section 580d bars a deficiency on a note when the property was sold under the deed of trust securing that note. No sale had occurred under the second deed of trust, so the statute did not bar a judgment on the second note. The court warned that the answer could differ if a lender splits what is really one loan into two notes to get around the statute. These loans were separate deals made two years apart.

DoDocument a second loan as a truly separate transaction: its own purpose, underwriting, note, and deed of trust, at a different time.
Don’tDon’t split one loan into a first and second deed of trust to manufacture a deficiency claim. The court flagged exactly that as an open question.

Note: the court decided only the § 580d question. It did not decide whether the one-action rule or another statute limits recovery in this situation.

FAQ

Default and remedies

What is the “one-action rule”?

A lender whose debt is secured by California real property has one form of action to collect it: foreclosure. It must look to the real property first, and it must include all of the real property security in that one action. A lender that sues on the note, takes a judgment, or helps itself to other assets first risks losing the security.

Law:Code Civ. Proc. § 726, subd. (a); Security Pacific National Bank v. Wozab (1990) 51 Cal.3d 991; Walker v. Community Bank (1974) 10 Cal.3d 729.

Can we collect a deficiency after a trustee’s sale?

Not from the borrower on the note that was foreclosed. After a sale under the power of sale, no deficiency may be owed or collected on that note. The statute says this does not, by itself, affect a guarantor’s liability or other pledged collateral, and it does not bar a suit on a truly separate note whose deed of trust was not the one foreclosed.

Law:Code Civ. Proc. § 580d, subds. (a), (b); Black Sky Capital, LLC v. Cobb (2019) 7 Cal.5th 156; Roseleaf Corp. v. Chierighino (1963) 59 Cal.2d 35.

If we foreclose in court instead, how much can we recover?

No more than the debt minus the fair value of the property as the court finds it, and never more than the debt minus the sale price. The application for the fair-value hearing must be filed within three months after the foreclosure sale.

Law:Code Civ. Proc. § 726, subd. (b); Black Sky Capital, LLC v. Cobb (2019) 7 Cal.5th 156.

What is a purchase-money loan, and why does it matter?

It is a loan tied to buying the property: a note taken back by the seller for part of the price, or a lender’s loan used to buy a one-to-four unit dwelling the buyer occupies. No deficiency may be owed or collected on these, and the protection cannot be waived. The rule also covers a refinance of a purchase-money home loan made on or after January 1, 2013, except for new money advanced. A seller who subordinated to a construction loan for commercial development was allowed to recover in one narrow line of cases.

Law:Code Civ. Proc. § 580b; DeBerard Properties, Ltd. v. Lim (1999) 20 Cal.4th 659; Spangler v. Memel (1972) 7 Cal.3d 603.

What can we charge the borrower to reinstate?

The amounts actually in default plus allowed costs. Costs of the foreclosure itself are limited to the listed items, and trustee’s or attorney’s fees for the foreclosure are capped by a statutory schedule based on the unpaid principal. Other legal fees spent protecting the security may be added to the debt if the loan documents allow it, but keep them separate.

Law:Civ. Code § 2924c, subds. (a), (c), (d); Caruso v. Great Western Savings (1991) 229 Cal.App.3d 667.

Can we get a receiver or an attachment while the foreclosure is pending?

A receiver may be available, especially where the deed of trust assigns rents or the property is at risk, but only on the grounds the statutes list. Attachment is generally not available on a claim secured by real property unless, without any act of the lender, the security has become valueless or has dropped below the amount owed. Ask counsel before filing either, so the request is framed in a way that does not create a one-action problem.

Law:Code Civ. Proc. §§ 564, 483.010, subd. (b), 483.012; Civ. Code § 2938.

Published court decisions involving other parties, summarized for educational purposes. Benjy Law Corporation was not involved in these cases. Facts are as described in the courts’ opinions. A decision states a legal rule; it does not predict how any other matter will turn out.

(310) 203-2650

Statewide California.